"Our results are consistent with previous research which found no relationship between rain acidity and lake acidity and explained lake acidity in terms of soil chemistry in the catchment area of the lakes". -Munshi
First of all, the article is not a peer reviewed paper. The second, he puts his name as a single author but writes as 'we have conducted blah blah'? Did he collect all these data points? Or, did he collect data from others and passing them as his own data? If this is a review article, he should cite the appropriate references rather than using pronoun 'we' to confuse people? What part of the data really belongs to his own work? My quick check of this article shows, the man does not even prove anything new but replicate(s) the previous findings. So, where is the beef? Is it him or others have done work?
The subject is interesting, but is it relevant to the topic? Not sure what respected Munshi wants to prove here? Showing his expertise in the acid rain field? How silly! First of all, the article is not a peer reviewed paper. The second, he puts his name as a single author but writes as 'we have conducted blah blah'? Did he collect all these data points? Or, did he collect data from others and passing them as his own data? If this is a review article, he should cite the appropriate references rather than using pronoun 'we' to confuse people? What part of the data really belongs to his own work? My quick check of this article shows, the man does not even prove anything new but replicate(s) the previous findings. So, where is the beef? Is it him or others have done work?
On Fri, Oct 21, 2016 at 10:28 PM, Msa40 <msa40@aol.com> wrote:
Respected "Munshi" sahib,The subject, "acid rain," that you wrote about is beyond my ken. I don't like to venture into unknown territory. So pleasewait for the knowledgeable to share your interest with you!Mohammad Asghar-----Original Message-----
From: Jamal Munshi <jamalmunshi@gmail.com>To: Msa40 <msa40@aol.com>
Cc: Khurshed Chowdhury <chowdhuryk@gmail.com>; Yahoogroups <mukto-mona@yahoogroups.com>; safiulhuda <safiulhuda@gmail.com>; barkatek <barkatek@yahoo.com>; ahmediqbal.bd <ahmediqbal.bd@gmail.com>; guhasb <guhasb@gmail.com>; shahdeeldar <shahdeeldar@gmail.com>; imran.ahmad.48 <imran.ahmad.48@gmail.com>; bhuiyan08 <bhuiyan08@hotmail.com>; tajhashmi <tajhashmi@gmail.com>; esty48 <esty48@hotmail.com>; jhelali2000 <jhelali2000@yahoo.com>; bangladesh-progressives <bangladesh-progressives@googlegroups.com >; anisur.rahman1 <anisur.rahman1@btinternet.com>; farida_majid <farida_majid@hotmail.com>
Sent: Fri, Oct 21, 2016 7:18 pm
Subject: Re: Linga Pooja
What about acid rain. Remember acid rain?
__._,_.___
