Dr. Ahmed Sharif was a Nastik. He was never a supporter of Razakar. I am not against Rabindranath's poems, short story, songs etc and hate Auyub Khan, Yahiya, Bhutto. Those writings give me a lot of pleasures but true are that Rabindranath was not the poet of the common peoples both Hindu & Muslims like Nazrul.
Politically he was very much biased. May be that was his limitation. He was guided by Bed, Uponishod. He didn't know Islam and Muslim well.
Bongbanga was supported by then east Bengal farmers (most of them was Muslims) and opposed by Kolkatta Jomidar (Rabindranath was also a Jomidar) and Rabindranath had supported them and had written "Amar Shonar Bangla" in favor of those oppressor Jomidar.
He proposed Hindi as the national Language of India instead of Bangla but Dr. Shhidullah had opposed as the roots of Hindi was Samakrti dominated by Hinduism. If Hindi was the national language who will reads all his writings? No body.
We should know the true history first then decide what we should accept or not.
Mosharraf Khokon
--- On Sat, 5/15/10, J.A. Chowdhury <Chwdhury@hotmail.com> wrote:
From: J.A. Chowdhury <Chwdhury@hotmail.com> Subject: RE: [ALOCHONA] Rabindranath:enemy of Bangladesh People n humanity To: alochona@yahoogroups.com Date: Saturday, May 15, 2010, 10:40 AM
After established of DU, Rabindronath Tagore came in DU Campus in 1922. He wrote his song "Jokon Porbe na Mor Payer Chinno....." Hemonto Mukopadday came in Dhaka just week before of his death in 1989. In Jogonnath Hall Mall, Hemonto said...Robindronath wrote this song here and now I am singing it here.(with Boudi). We know Robindronath always MEANS Greater Bangladesh, not east Bengal or west Bengal. His Bengal was Noakhali to Shiliguri, Barishal to Medinipur, He never think separately east Bengal. We feel proud he was our Poet, poet of Bengal. We should not say he is a great poet of Subcontinent. We should say Kobi Guru is our Poet. Indian Pakistani or other country's people can say- Robindronath is a poet of subcontinent. Robindronath is a world poet "Bisso-kobi" minimum 5 countries national Anthon written by Rabindronath, India Nepal Srilanka Maldip and Bangladesh. If anybody say Rabindranath was an enemy of Bangladesh people and humanity.... we know, they are nobody except- Paki minded Rajakar who want "Pak sar jamin shad bad" instead of Amar Sonar Bangla.
J.A.Chowdhury
To: alochona@yahoogroup s.com From: aminul_islam_ raj@yahoo. com Date: Tue, 11 May 2010 21:28:59 -0700 Subject: Re: [ALOCHONA] Rabindranath: enemy of Bangladesh People n humanity
Mr Muhosin Ali,
I have showed how rabindranath is a enemy of Humanity n people of Bangladesh.I presented some facts. These are not created by me.First I came to know about this by Dr Ahmed Sharif . In one of his article published in Uttoradhikar , a literary quarterly of Bang la Academy. It is noted that Mr Sharif was one of those who came forward in support of Rabindranath when there was a strong propaganda against Rabindra nath.Dr sarif Showed How Rabindranath oppressed his subjects.
If any body snached ones religious right or copelled one to follow other religion then he is enemy of humanity.If someone stand against establishing university in bangladesh he is enemy of Bangladesh.
aminul
--- On Sun, 5/9/10, Dr. M. Mohsin Ali <drmohsinali@ yahoo.com> wrote:
From: Dr. M. Mohsin Ali <drmohsinali@ yahoo.com> Subject: [ALOCHONA] Rabindranath: enemy of Bangladesh People n humanity To: alochona@yahoogroup s.com Date: Sunday, May 9, 2010, 6:26 AM
IT IS A NONSENSE PROPAGANDA LIKE THE AYUB-MONAYEM REGIME OF PAKISTAN DURING 1960'S AGAINST THE BENGALI CULTURE. THEY WERE ALREADY THROWN OUT OF THE HISTORY OF PAKISTAN AND BANGLADESH THE BRAVE PEOPLE OF BANGLADESH.
I AM WONDERING HOW ALOCHONA GROUP IS ENCOURAGING SUCH PAKISTANI OLD PROPAGANDA AND TRYING TO DEFAME KOBI GURU.
--- On Sat, 5/8/10, Md. Aminul Islam <aminul_islam_ raj@yahoo. com> wrote:
Rabindranath: enemy of Bangladesh People n humanity
Dear All,
Do you know that Poet" Bshakobi " rabindranath
1 )compelled his Muslim subjects Giving Chanda For Puja 2) compelled his Muslim subjects giving Tax for Bared ( Lari rakharv jonno kor Adai korto)
3)He never established a single school in his jomidari in Bangladesh( silaidoh , shajatpur or potisosr)
4)He opposed and protested the establishment of Dhaka University
5)oppression on subjects by Rabindranath is a well established Truth.
He was getting Khetabs , as supported the British colonial regime when nazrul was jailed for his role against the British regime.
But sometimes some so called manobotabadi ask for establish the ideal of This rabindranath.
What kind of "Manobotabadi was Rabindranath n his supporters?
Hotmail: Free, trusted and rich email service. Get it now.
__._,_.___
[Disclaimer: ALOCHONA Management is not liable for information contained in this message. The author takes full responsibility.] To unsubscribe/subscribe, send request to alochona-owner@egroups.com
