Punjabis are the biggest Ethnic group of former West Pakistan, wrongfully calling itself Pakistan but since their language is written in Dev Nagri Script or Hindu-like Script and they do not want to learn that, their Languages has almost become a Non Written language. This is why they have no choice but to accept Urdu as their National Language.
In Pakistan, Urdu is more understood language than any other language so, it sounds practical to keep it as National Language. Since all of them can understand Hindi, the Mother Language of Urdu, Hindi or old Indian Urdu and Punjabi words have been creeping up in Pakistani Urdu for more than a quarter century because of smuggled-in Indian Movies. Since 1990's because of Indian Satellite TV Channels this has gained more strength.
Since it has become a part of Islam of Mollaas to teach Hate against Non Moslims, anybody making some sense is always declared an Indian or Foreign Agent, Kaafir etc all the time. Nothing new in Mollaa Anis's accusations against you.
From: Shamim Chowdhury <veirsmill@yahoo.com>
It's not understandable why you jumping from one topic to another. You wrote something which has no base and the information was bogus, I just pointed it out for you to correct, instead you jump to another topic with another baseless bogus data. You need to do a little study before you write.
Anyway, what wrong you see when India picks up one of its own homegrown language Hindi as India's official language beside English? Just for your information Hindi is NOT India's national language. India does not have any national language. India's constitution allows other Indian states to choose their own state language as they wish to.
On the other hand Pakistan's Official as well as National language is Urdu which is a foreign language to majority of Pakistanis other then some Mohajirs (repatriated Indians) in Karachi. There are 5 times more Urdu speaking people in India then Pakistan and there is more then one state in India whose official language is Urdu. According to all linguists Urdu is nothing but a form of Hindi using Arabic alphabet. Language has not much history other then Mughals picked up this made up language for running the courts and some official business with native Muslim Indians.
Mr. Anis bashed India for imposing their homegrown language Hindi on their own people but overlooked Pakistan imposing a foreign language on their own national. We all know about the fate of our own language Bangle in the hands of brutal Pakistani juntas when they declined our demand Bangla to be one of the national languages of then Pakistan though Bangla was spoken by majority people of Pakistan. Repressive Pakistani government killed scores of people when they brought our rally demanding Bangla as national language on February 21st of 1952. Pakistan dire attempt to alter our Bangla alphabets with Arabic went into vain when heroic Bengalis challenged that outrageous conspiracy.
Pakistan's support for 21st February as International Mother Language Day UN charter was nothing but just a makeover of their dreadful deeds of 1952 and their after against the people of Bangladesh. Pakistan was always against Bengalis and Bangladesh and will remain so for unseen future.
I do not want to reply to his comments about Home Minister because it's just tasteless and nasty.
Thanks,
Shamim Chowdhury
Maryland, U.S.A.
--- On Thu, 1/6/11, anis.ahmed@netzero.net <anis.ahmed@netzero.net> wrote:
> Unless
> Mr. Shamim Chowdhury is a die-hard supporter of RAW
> manifesto than most Indian Citizens (more than people
> of West Bengal, Assam, Punjab,
> Kashmir, etc.) he would not make any comment after
> reading my latest and corrected (please find below)
> email. Perhaps,
> Mr. Shamim Chowdhury and his RAW supporters of Bangladeshi
> origin know very well that India does not have any official
> language but she (India) imposes Hindi as official
> throughout her all states including West Bengal, Assam,
> Punjab, etc. Secondly,
> Indian Government and it's RAW made Bangladesh as
> Brothel through Whore (Home) Minister in the name of
> secularism by eliminating
> Islam. http://groups.yahoo.com/group/Ovimot/message/672 http://groups.yahoo.com/group/Ovimot/message/682 Anybody
> can judge about India and
> RAW's role in her own nation and to neighboring country,
> Bangladesh. It's
> not the question of Anti-India, it is about patriotism and
> integrity. Thanks
> for your
> understanding. Anis
> Ahmed Date: Wed, 5 Jan
> 2011 10:09:11 -0800 (PST)
> Subject: [notun_bangladesh] Re: Original Resolution on
> International Mother Language Day: Correction
> Reply-To: notun_bangladesh@yahoogroups.com
>
> I am not sure what Mr. Anis
> has in mind other then bashing India to serve his
> master Pakistan. He will suggest things that are baseless
> and absolutely untrue.
> His posting about international mother language day is just
> another anti Indian
> hoax.
>
> Here is the truth, I also put the link for you to verify.
>
> Link to UNESO web portal:
> http://portal.unesco.org/education/en/ev.php-URL_ID=28672&URL_DO=DO_TOPIC&URL_SECTION=-512.html
>
> Resolution adopted by the 30th Session of UNESCO's
> General Conference (1999)
> 30 C/DR.35 (submitted by Bangladesh and Saudi Arabia;
> supported by Oman,
> Benin,Sri Lanka, Egypt, the Russian Federation, Bahamas,
> Dominican Republic,
> Belarus, the Philippines, Côte d'Ivoire, India,
> Honduras, Gambia, the Federated
> States of Micronesia, Vanuatu, Indonesia, Papua New Guinea,
> Comoros, Pakistan,
> Islamic Republic of Iran, Lithuania, Italy and the Syrian
> Arab Republic)
> relating to paragraph 05204, the Commission recommends that
> the General
> Conference proclaim "International Mother Language
> Day" to be observed on 21
> February.
>
> Thanks,
> Shamim
maryland, U.S.A
>
__._,_.___
