I was playing with the following pairs of possible headlines to report incidences:
1. 5 Hindu women were raped by XYZ party cadres vs. 5 humans (men can also be raped, right?) were raped by miscreants
2. 10 houses and 1 temple were burnt down in village V by XYZ caders vs. 10 houses and 1 place of worship were burnt down by miscreants
3. The chief of a political party P instigated his followers to attack the members of a perceived rival group vs. Narendra Modi (Khaleda Zia) instigated his (her) cadres to attack Muslims (Hindus) in Gujarat (Bhola)
I could have come up with more pairs. But the message is this: We are not perfect yet. We still have prejudices and sectarian, religious, and racial biases, let alone the political motives. We have seen reports that law enforcement agencies sometimes take part in communal riots. We have seen a recent news item sent by Mr. Parmer. A SC man's hands were chopped off as because he drank water out of the pitcher of a caste hindu. Sometimes some news items are sensitive and may provoke violence. In those situations it becomes necessary to tailor the news. A human rights activist cannot remain indifferent to such possible biases. It is his duty to shed light on it. Otherwise, the reporting will be incomplete. It will, however, be necessary to investigate and find the real truth. Even if the investigation reveals that no particular religious or racial hatred worked as the motive, the basic fact still remains that 2 muslims and 2 SC men were killed brutally by BSF. We still live in a world where a hindu is killed only because he is hindu, a muslim is killed only because he is a muslim, and an SC man is killed only because he is an SC man.
Let us learn not to be too obsessed with possible appeasement policies adopted by "pseudo secularists."
From: qar <qrahman@netscape.net>
To: mukto-mona@yahoogroups.com
Sent: Tuesday, April 17, 2012 4:55 AM
Subject: Re: [mukto-mona] Re: Four cattle smugglers killed by BSF
To: mukto-mona@yahoogroups.com
Sent: Tuesday, April 17, 2012 4:55 AM
Subject: Re: [mukto-mona] Re: Four cattle smugglers killed by BSF
To me the headline means - those kids were killed by BSF just because they were scheduled caste and Muslim. You can believe this story, but don't ask me to do so. I will wait until Kirity Roy learns to report news (or stories) without any hidden agenda. I was referring to a very particular headline that I have quoted in my comment, which was the hallmark of BNP/Jamat.
>>>>>>>>>> I understand where you are coming from. HOWEVER it is like "Corrupting" news as per individual will. I also find it amusing that, you think "Kirti Roy" has a "Hidden" agenda to help MUSLIMs.
Why is it so hard to imagine there are Muslims who suffer like rest of the population?
There are plenty of theories about "Hidden agendas" but sometime explanations are the simplest of all. BNP/Jammat are POLITICAL parties and they are no different than political parties in this planet. They want to go back to power!!
That is all. I do not know why Indian authorities are so careless about suffering of poor Bangladeshi and Indians? We are good neighbors (Based on Sub-continent standard) and have a lot of similarities. So what is stopping us from acting like genuine partners?
Guess Indian policies are the biggest enemies of India...
Why is it so hard to imagine there are Muslims who suffer like rest of the population?
There are plenty of theories about "Hidden agendas" but sometime explanations are the simplest of all. BNP/Jammat are POLITICAL parties and they are no different than political parties in this planet. They want to go back to power!!
That is all. I do not know why Indian authorities are so careless about suffering of poor Bangladeshi and Indians? We are good neighbors (Based on Sub-continent standard) and have a lot of similarities. So what is stopping us from acting like genuine partners?
Guess Indian policies are the biggest enemies of India...
-----Original Message----- From: Jiten Roy <jnrsr53@yahoo.com> To: mukto-mona <mukto-mona@yahoogroups.com> Sent: Sat, Apr 14, 2012 6:28 am Subject: RE: [mukto-mona] Re: Four cattle smugglers killed by BSF
To me the headline means - those kids were killed by BSF just because they were scheduled caste and Muslim. You can believe this story, but don't ask me to do so. I will wait until Kirity Roy learns to report news (or stories) without any hidden agenda. I was referring to a very particular headline that I have quoted in my comment, which was the hallmark of BNP/Jamat. By the way, the last paragraph of your comment was unnecessary; it was intended to irritate someone only. Jiten Roy
|
__._,_.___