Banner Advertiser

Thursday, June 18, 2009

[ALOCHONA] Tipaimukh team loses credibility before inspection



 
 

IN THE past few days and weeks, a number of ministers of the Awami League-led government have come out with their tacit support for the controversial Indian plan for construction of dam/s on the river Barak at Tipaimukh in Assam, some 200 kilometres upstream of the Bangladesh border.

 

Not only have they harped on the now-clichéd Indian government's 'assurance' that it would not divert water from the dam/s, that the dam/s would not harm Bangladesh in any way and that Bangladesh stands to be benefited from the dam/s, one of them, the commerce minister, even claimed that 'those who are talking too much against construction of the dam are talking without knowing anything'. On Tuesday, the chairman of the parliamentary standing committee on the water resources ministry, Abdur Razzak, who will lead a team of parliamentarians and experts to Tipaimukh to inspect the controversial project and assess its possible effects on Bangladesh.


   After presiding over a meeting of the committee, which resolved to send a team of parliamentarians and experts to inspect the Tipaimukh project and assess its possible ecological effects on Bangladesh, Razzak, who was the water resources minister of the previous AL government, told reporters that Bangladeshi experts who have criticised the Tipaimukh Dam/s in different talk-shows on private television channels have little knowledge of the project. He also requested 'all to refrain from talking on the issue without studying it thoroughly'.

 

His comments are not only unfortunate but irresponsible as well for they undermine the credibility of the team that he will lead before its inspection of the Tipaimukh project and subsequent findings and recommendations, on the basis of which the government will come up with a formal reaction to New Delhi about the planned dam/s. Also, Razzak apparently sought to make the controversy a partisan issue when he claimed that the project 'went ahead as per the discussion and the resolutions of a meeting of the Joint Rivers Commission in New Delhi in 2003', when the Bangladesh Nationalist Party-led alliance government was in power.


   The government needs to realise that the Tipaimukh controversy is an issue of national interest and that the debate over it must not degenerate into partisan bickering. It is indeed welcome that the parliamentary committee has decided to send a team of parliamentarians to Tipaimukh for inspection and assessment of the dam project. However, the lawmakers on the committee – be they of the treasury or opposition benches – need to realise that they are on the team as representatives of the people, not members of one political party or the other.

 

They should take to their task free of any prejudice or misconception. Regrettably, the designated leader of the team, as his comments tend to indicate, seems to have been overcome by both prejudice and misconception. When the team leader is guided by prejudice and misconception, it is bound to influence other members of the team.


   Hence, we would expect that the members of the inspection team will leave behind whatever misconception and prejudices that they might have and take to their task with an open mind. Hopefully, their findings and recommendations will be based on scientific evidences and guided by national interests. We would also demand that a detailed debate on their findings and recommendations be held on the floor of the parliament. Here, too, the parliamentarians need to rise above their partisan loyalty and address the issue as representatives of the people.

 

http://www.newagebd.com/2009/jun/18/edit.html




__._,_.___


[Disclaimer: ALOCHONA Management is not liable for information contained in this message. The author takes full responsibility.]
To unsubscribe/subscribe, send request to alochona-owner@egroups.com




Your email settings: Individual Email|Traditional
Change settings via the Web (Yahoo! ID required)
Change settings via email: Switch delivery to Daily Digest | Switch to Fully Featured
Visit Your Group | Yahoo! Groups Terms of Use | Unsubscribe

__,_._,___