Sardar Patel was a communal leader and his ideas for non-Hindus were not so good. I have read many posts about Pakistan and hate being the concept behind it, which is untrue. It was more like "FEAR" which drove many Indians to ask for a different homeland. If you look back our "Father of the nation" Bangabandu was also a strong supporter of the concept of Pakistan. Back then Muslims did not feel secured in India where communal forces inside congress and other parties became very strong. In fact many historians noted tacit support of congress in creation of Pakistan.
Albeit many Muslims were against "Breaking up India" but a good number wanted that to happen. According to Maulana Abul Kalam Azad even Jinnah did not want to establish Pakistan but wanted to use this concept to bargain for Indian Muslims.
We know the history that followed.
India is facing a very interesting future. If Namo( Modi) want to go back to his old politics (Communal), he will destroy India for decades. If he learn from his past "Mistakes" and wish to transform India into a modern state, he'll have that option in front of him near future.
I do not think India is going through any "Fundamental" change in caste system but it is bending a bit to the power of democracy. In democracy everyone has one vote and thus a lower caste Hindu has as much power as a Brahmin. So the politics is adjusting to this new reality (Beside very strong violent communist movement gaining popularity in many parts).
Recent rape epidemic shows India did not change that much. It is a classic example of how an old civilization is struggling to cope with being connected to "Modern world".
India has one superiority over her neighbors (Beside size and power). It has a culture of democracy and justice system (Police, court) that is mature and somewhat independent.
India has many tests in front of it. One is being a responsible regional power or becoming a regional bully (Who want to lead through fear). In domestic arena India has to look into some fundamental reform.
I wish them success in this new phase.
Shalom!
From: Subimal Chakrabarty <subimal@yahoo.com>
To: mukto-mona <mukto-mona@yahoogroups.com>
Sent: Mon, Jan 27, 2014 5:00 pm
Subject: Re: [mukto-mona] Modi's Caste and Hindutva Political Strategies ISP III Jan 2014
Sent from my iPhone
__._,_.___
****************************************************
Mukto Mona plans for a Grand Darwin Day Celebration:
Call For Articles:
http://mukto-mona.com/wordpress/?p=68
http://mukto-mona.com/banga_blog/?p=585
****************************************************
VISIT MUKTO-MONA WEB-SITE : http://www.mukto-mona.com/
****************************************************
"I disapprove of what you say, but I will defend to the death your right to say it".
-Beatrice Hall [pseudonym: S.G. Tallentyre], 190
Change settings via the Web (Yahoo! ID required)
Change settings via email: Switch delivery to Daily Digest | Switch to Fully Featured
Visit Your Group | Yahoo! Groups Terms of Use | Unsubscribe
__,_._,___
Monday, January 27, 2014
Re: [mukto-mona] Modi's Caste and Hindutva Political Strategies ISP III Jan 2014
He is building the tallest statue of Sardar Ballavbhai Patel who happened to be a veteran Congress leader. He did not pick Savarkar. His slogan is not Hindutva
>>>>>>>>> Remember Khondokar Mustaq was also in BAL senior leader. In fact our famed "Four national leaders" were fired from BAL but Mustaq was kept with the party.
-----Original Message-----
The content of the article has come as a real surprise to me. Narendra Modi does not belong to higher caste and he boasts of his caste credential! Did he get easy approval of RSS or there was a tension between RSS and BJP when Modi's name was proposed as the PM candidate? Easy approval means RSS is undergoing ideological reforms. If this is really so, is the current RSS defying the doctrines of it's founding fathers?
Empowerment of the Scheduled castes and OBCs in the modern time India is not new. India has witnessed PM, CM, and President from SC/OBC. But none of them was from BJP or RSS.
I have heard that RSS trains non-Brahmins to become priests for the SC people. By doing this are they not defying Hindu casteism? Is it a temporary measure or a strategic retreat to capture state power? We have already seen what a shrewd policy Modi is adopting. He is building the tallest statue of Sardar Ballavbhai Patel who happened to be a veteran Congress leader. He did not pick Savarkar. His slogan is not Hindutva, but Indianism.
I hope Mr. Puniyani will enlighten us with more articles like this.
Modi's Caste and Hindutva Political Strategies
Ram Puniyani
As Narnedra Modi was close to being nominated the Prime Ministerial candidate, another Modi, Sushil Modi, flaunted Modi's backward caste origins. Recently (Jan 2014) in a public rally in Delhi, Narerndra Modi himself brandished his caste while speaking at a public rally. At one level it is surprising that Modi is showcasing his caste, as the aim of RSS, whose trained swayamsevak (volunteer) he is, is to forge a monolithic Hindu identity, papering over the caste differences and underplaying its inherent hierarchy. Hindutva, the RSS politics, is essentially an ideology based on a caste pyramid, where the different castes have a well defined place. The caste system gets its strength through subordinating the dominated castes. Dominated castes, dalits-OBCS, assuming Hindu identity, over and above their caste identity, is the fulcrum of strength of Hindutva politics.
Caste has been the major phenomenon, with which the Hindutva politics had to engage with. The beginning of RSS was more as a reaction to low castes coming up in the society. In 1920s when the dalits launched Non Brahman movement, aimed to fight against landlord-Brahmin combine, the upper castes, came forward to lay the foundation of RSS. This formation was aiming at Hindu Nation, in contrast to the agenda of Ambedkar who was talking of caste annihilation and was conceptualizing the concept of social justice in the framework of rising Indian Nationalism. RSS was also opposed to the national movement, which recognized the need for transformation of caste hierarchy, towards the values of equality. At this point of time the Hindutva ideologues like Golwalkar, upheld the Hindu holy books which had caste equations ingrained in them. These ideologues, overlooking the cruelty of caste system, glorified it as the basis and strength of Hindu society. With independence and the coming into being of Indian Constitution the march of dalits towards equality took the next step aided by the affirmative action provided by Indian Constitution. They did start the journey for their own share sky.
The changes in social scenario by 1980s led to a situation whereby upper caste felt that this undeserving section is being treated like 'son-in-laws' of the Governments in matters of education and jobs. They felt that their 'deserving' children are not able to get their due share of admissions and jobs. The result was anti-dalit violence in Ahmadabad in 1980s. Later the anti OBC violence in mid 1980s, opposing the promotion of OBCs in jobs was witnessed. With Mandal Commission coming in 1990s, the discomfort of upper caste was articulated by RSS progeny, who for electoral compulsions did not formally oppose the Mandal but diverted the social attention by enhancing the mobilization for Ram temple in a big way.
Meanwhile RSS planned for social engineering by which the dalits were co-opted into Hindutva politics and at places put in the forefront like in Babri demolition and also in the anti Muslim violence in Gujarat in particular. The anti-minority violence plays the role of bringing religious identity o the fore. In case of dalits through communal violence 'Hindu identity' came in as the overshadowing one, overshadowing the caste identity. After every case of anti minority violence, the Hindu identity became bigger for dalits. The recent case of Muzzafarnagar violence is the good example to observe this phenomenon. Here the Jats-Muslim bridges were broken through this violence and more so by transforming the Jat identity to the Hindu identity, by showing the fear of Muslims. Earlier also through this social engineering the dalit OBCs like Uma Bharati, Kalyan Singh, Vinay Katiyar have been brought in the forefront of RSS scheme of politics, through the act of Babri demolition and other related communal agenda. With this social engineering one can see the section of dalits veering towards this divisive politics.
At another level there is a conscious ploy through floating organizations like Samajik Samrasta Manch (Social Assimilation Platform), which talks of caste harmony while retaining caste inequality. This idea is in total contrast to the idea of Ambedkar for whom caste annihilation had to be the central agenda of dalit politics. While Ambedkar painfully drew attention to the plight of dalits and struggled for justice for them RSS has subtly and openly opposed the affirmative action for dalits and never raised its voice against atrocities on dalits. Agenda of communal politics is a clever ploy. At one level it opposes all affirmative action for the dominated castes, at another level it co-opts them and at yet another level it talks of harmony between different castes.
There is a twin track strategy as far as caste question is concerned. On one side it aims to project Modi's backward caste identity, and this is for an electoral appeal. At another level it also aims to bring in overarching Hindu identity over and above the caste identity, while retaining the caste pyramid. The overarching Hindu identity is constructed through communal violence, through projecting the fear of the 'other', Muslim or Christian, as the one's threatening 'we the Hindus'. At ideological level it propagated 'Integral Humanism' propounded by Deendayal Upadhyay. This concept of Integral Humanism says that we Hindus believe that different Varnas have come from same Virat Purush (Grand Man). From his mouth came Brahmins, from arms Khstriyas, from thighs Vaishyas and from feet the Shudras were created. It menas that all these Varnas-castes are complimentary to each other.
Modi took this concept to spiritual level, in his recent book, Karmayoga, published by the state information department. In this book Modi says, "Scavenging must have been a spiritual experience for the Valmiki caste, "At some point of time, somebody must have got the enlightenment that it is their (Valmikis') duty to work for the happiness of the entire society and the Gods; that they have to do this job bestowed upon them by Gods; and that this job of cleaning up should continue as an internal spiritual activity for centuries. This should have continued generation after generation. It is impossible to believe that their ancestors did not have the choice of adopting any other work or business." This spiritual experience is reserved for the 'Valmikis', a sub-caste among Dalits, which has been condemned to scavenging jobs for centuries. The functions of the caste are also being glorified and propagated by many a Godmen, one of whom Pandurang Shastri Athwaley clearly stated that any deviation from the pre-assigned caste duty is detrimental for the society. Another God man Sri Sri Ravi Shanker has been propagating about caste harmony through his writing.
There is no linear relationship between this politics and its strategies. This politics, Hindutva, wants to uphold the caste hierarchy in a subtle way and adopts different tactics in dealing with the caste question. Undoubtedly once the non upper caste become assertive as 'Hindus' through ideological indoctrination and become icons of Hindutva politics; that is the biggest 'success' of this politics. Modi being a Hindutva icon, being an OBC, is a big leap for Hindutva agenda of upholding caste system and at the same time making stronger forays on the electoral battlefield.
--
Issues in Secular Politics
III January 2014
Response only to ram.puniyani@gmail.com
Your email settings: Individual Email|Traditional