I find myself in full agreement with your assertions. On what grounds can Mr. Munshi be called as an outstanding intellectual of our time. Would Mr. Bahar kindly elaborate.
WE really know how to cheapen the value of words and titles.
Sad !!!
To: abidbahar@yahoo.com; 6064@yahoogroups.com; abdul_momen@hotmail.com; abutaher@gmail.com; shurovies.coll@gmail.com; afsaruddin2000@yahoo.com; aftab_kazmi@hotmail.com; ajmol.ali@treas.state.nj.us; akhter@erols.com; aknahkhan@yahoo.com; malamgir1@aol.com; albarakat@intermaxinc.com; ali_a_chowdhury@hotmail.com; alochona@yahoogroups.com; anisahmed63@yahoo.com; manonbike2@yahoo.com; ask@citechco.net; atq111@yahoo.com; awahed@hotmail.com; ayesha_rahman21@hotmail.com; ayeshakabir@yahoo.com; baainews@yahoo.com; banglarnari@yahoogroups.com; beautyanwar@hotmail.com; ben_inda@yahoo.com; bidrohee@yahoo.com; bushrakhan24@gmail.com; caphurdi@dhaka.net; celeti@aol.com; chabinazrul@yahoo.com; chowdhuryhkhan@yahoo.com; dhuq@msn.com; dick_timm@yahoo.com; dip1971@hotmail.com; faisal.quader@gxs.com; fareez.ahmed@gmail.com; farhadmazhar@hotmail.com; faria_shukhee@hotmail.com; farida_majid@hotmail.com; farukahmed_bd@yahoo.com; frahman@telesat.com; fsobhan@hotmail.com; g_faroo1@hotmail.com; gmehraj@aol.com; hafi2ur@aol.com; hanif9161751342@aol.com; hares.sayed@dc.gov; hashimn@bellsouth.net
From: islam1234@msn.com
Date: Fri, 6 Mar 2009 02:07:05 -0500
Subject: [ALOCHONA] MILITANCY-MBI MUNSHI/
Dear Abid>
Are you a paid attack dog for Munshi? From where you got the idea, that he is an outstanding intellectual of our time? Can you send me a single publication from Munshi in any prestigious journal in America or Europe? There is another worshipper like you, who edited Munshi's India Doctrine. His qualifications to write a book review? He has a master's degree in sociology from Bangladesh! Lord have mercy—this satisfies your criteria for intellectualism? Here is a challenge for you and MBI Munshi. Submit India Doctrine to New York Times book Review editor for an intellectual analysis. If NY Time verifies that Mr.Munshi's assertions, innuendos, accusations and speculative statements have basis in fact---I will give Mr.Munshi—the Key to my house in Washington D.C. However, if the NY Times say, it is wildly speculative book with lots of personal opinion, unfounded fear, and uncorroborated statements--
SaifDevdas
islam1234@msn.com
Mr Deddas,
It is true compared to Bangladesh, India had been powerful and is increasingly becoming powerful so is Bangladesh through it baby steps. But history shows from the time of Tajuddin through Sheikh Mujib and the other pro- Indians that Bangladesh's unconditional friendship with India only made Bangladesh lose its steam to even becoming a bottomless busket. All these experiences show that we have to be careful with an enemy and its mindset which MBI Munshi calls the "INDIA DOCTRINE." This enemy pretends like your best friend. Munshi that you call "foolish" warns us that we the independent-minded Bangladeshis shouldn't remain subsurviant to India. We fought against the mighty Pakistan the Paki Razakars with Mujib's "Chilli powder, Bhatee Marbo etc" to become independent, now Munshi warns us to watch the "pretentious friend" and the Indi razakars and the lost souls like you who want us to think that the earth is flat and India can do anything it wants.
By the way, Immam Hossain was not foolish, as you think, he became shahid and set the example of fighting evil and today if there was no such example Iran would still remain to USA what you suggest Bangladesh should remain to India. To me you are so lost that you call MBI Munshi's warnings as "militancy".My question is how do you know so much when you seem to have never developed an inner eye to understand things around you. I wouldn't call it a result of birth defect but I see some people are not so luckey to be gifted.
Your seeking of the truth will require an inner-mind and to know how to think from outside the box. It appears to me that you are so afraid staying inside the box that you are trying to find another smaller box inside that box.
Good luck to find a petit box but I don't see any there. But for your information, Mr. Munshi is in outside the box and can see you trying to hide for no reason except that you think irronously the world is flat.
Finally, before the Japanese defeated Russia, people thought white people are the master race. I hope Mr Das you keep some hope in humanity not on the Indian brahmo. Ofcourse I agree with you we should also keep hoping that India will change its racist mindset of Brahmon rule, the India doctrine. Instead of mixing up I suggest that you deal with our outstanding issues with Pakistan and Mr. Munshi with our problems in India Bangladesh relations. This will keep both of you away fighting with each other and you a little wiser.
From: SAIF Davdas <islam1234@msn.
To: 6064@yahoogroups.
Sent: Wednesday, March 4, 2009 9:54:35 PM
Subject: MILITANCY-MBI MUNSHI
Dear Friends>
MBI Munshi, you write---"Creation of a regional task force with tactical operations capabilities and extra-territorial functions could threaten the internal stability of the country and make it a target for insurgents and terrorists who had until now posed no threat to Bangladesh's interests". Very interesting indeed!
I would argue, my dear Munshi, more than our national security or dignity---common sense dictates---unpreced
You write, "For India to secure its political and military supremacy and control over the South Asian region it has become necessary for it to continuously maintain and protect her lead over other economies even by unfair means such as sabotage, fomenting and encouraging political instability in neighboring countries". My question to You Mr.Munshi---
Intellectual and moral Bankruptcy of your anti-India posture is truly sickening. Your venomous attack on India surpasses the foolishness of Hamas and Hezbollah's militant anti-Israel stance. The US, the Russians, and the EU have already declared---the next century will be an Indian and Chinese century. Only the militant Pakis and you think otherwise on this very vital issue. The Indians, armed with the largest Scientist force in the world, are beating the hell out of the Americans in every field. In last five years, more than Three Million Indians left USA for lucrative jobs in India. Doesn't common sense dictate that we the Bangladeshis also recognize this reality and act accordingly? After Mangle Pandey's revolution against the British in 1857---the wise Hindus, decided to beat the Brits by obeying them and learn from them. As a result, the British built the finest engineering schools in India---owing to that, India landed on Moon in 2008! Back then, the Muslims listened to scholars like you---not that Kafir Sir Syed Ahmed Khan---with devastating and disastrous far reaching consequences for the Muslims of the world! Islamic history of last 1000 years is replete with these militant voices. How very sad and unfortunate indeed. Will we Muslims ever learn?
SaifDevdas
islam1234@msn.com
_t.
Windows Live™: Life without walls. Check it out.
Windows Live™ Contacts: Organize your contact list. Check it out.
__._,_.___
[Disclaimer: ALOCHONA Management is not liable for information contained in this message. The author takes full responsibility.]
To unsubscribe/subscribe, send request to alochona-owner@egroups.com
Your email settings: Individual Email|Traditional
Change settings via the Web (Yahoo! ID required)
Change settings via email: Switch delivery to Daily Digest | Switch to Fully Featured
Visit Your Group | Yahoo! Groups Terms of Use | Unsubscribe
Change settings via the Web (Yahoo! ID required)
Change settings via email: Switch delivery to Daily Digest | Switch to Fully Featured
Visit Your Group | Yahoo! Groups Terms of Use | Unsubscribe
__,_._,___