[ALOCHONA] Re: Was Bangabandu like Castro of Cuba?

Dear Alochok Turkman

Good points! Though of course you know I am referring to Castro's
more negative traits - secret police, supreme authority, no political
parties, no press freedom etc etc. As you know these were the
emerging traits of Sheikh Mujib and hence the comparison.

Many of the successes of Castro's Cuba would not have been possible
without the Russia's deep vested interest in its stability.
Bangladesh had no such well wisher. Not even India. And these
successes also depended on Castro's continued leadership and
administrative skills. Some 30-40% of Mujib's followers deserted him
following his administrative failures.

He is like Castro when we compare their negatives.

Mujib's departure was the second biggest tragedy of Desh.

Mujib's departure from the principles that led to the War of
Independence was the biggest tragedy of Desh. It set the stage and
the tone for all the abysmal failures that have followed since.

Sigh!

Regards

Ezajur Rahman
Kuwait

--- In alochona@yahoogroups.com, S Turkman <turkman@...> wrote:
>
> Yeah but Bangladesh would then have highest Literacy Rate in the
world like Cuba and would not have been one of the poorest country on
earth either.
>  
> Cuba is 6 times richer than Bangladesh, Education and Medical is
free, Un-employment Rate is near Zero, Housing is free, nobody is
poor in Cuba and has more Ph.Ds, Physicians, Surgeons and Engineers
per Capita than any other country on earth. Actually, Cuba lends her
Physicians and Engineers to friendly countries for free. Do we have
any Physicians and Engineers to lend?
>  
> If he was like Castro, his departure was the biggest tragedy
Bangladesh had faced and his Assassins were the biggest Enemies of
Bangla.
>
> --- On Sun, 8/31/08, ezajur <ezajur.rahman@...> wrote:
>
>
>
>
>
>
> Had Mujib lived he would have continued as a dictator - not like
> Mussolini (come on!) but as a Fidel Castro (bad enough!)
>
> Though after seeing all the pompous AL middlemen strutting around
in
> their black waistcoats on National Mourning Day, as if all their
> years of lies and thievery were vindicated, made me feel that we
> should call them - the Black Coats, quite a Fascist term!
>
> Pity our poor country. Even our heros are killers or thieves.
>
> --- In alochona@yahoogroup s.com, mahathir of bd
> <wouldbemahathirofb d@...> wrote:
> >
> >  Reading mujib's lectures and seeing his failure na d fate, it
> seems to me that Mujib was a boss, not a leader.
> >  
> >  Becuase leaders never loss there popularity to such a low level
> that Mujib lost.
> >
> >
> >
> >
> > আল্লাহ যাকে যখন ইচ্ছা
> ক্ষমতা দান করেন,মাইনাস টু
> ফরমুলায় তাই হাসেন
> > http://www.microsco piceye.blogspot. com/
> >
> > --- On Fri, 8/15/08, abid bahar <abidbahar@ ..> wrote:
> >
> > > Bangabandu, Vs. Mousalini of Italy, Striking Similarities:
Please
> Read!
> > Abid Bahar
> >  
> > Bangabandu's Fourth Amendment is only the tip of the form of
> his "dictatorship. "(1) There are more details, the use of Mujib
> dress, Mujib Bahini, Lal bahini, Rakhi bahini and other
paramilitary
> forces, the extreme hero-worship tendency among his followers,
> indiscriminate killing of the opponents, arresting even the elderly
> statesman like Bhasani, favouratism to its party members,  and so
> many other similarities  with Mousalini, the Italian leader and
> with Spain's Francisco that when I found out,  I personally  was
> shocked (I was a former Mujib -lover)and have been writing
eversince
> about the sickness. 
> >  
> >  I asked myself, howcome there are so many similarities in a
> country far away from Europe. The answer I found is in political
> Science such a political trend is identified
> as Fascism. Mousalini even did similar things like Bangabandu
did,
> the latter standing in the parliament, declared that he
> couldn't use "Lal Ghora,"which he actually did but he wanted it
to
> be more severe on the opponents. 
> >  
> > There are also many similarities between Bangabandu's BAKSAL and
> other Third World Fascists as Sadam's socialist bath party, the
> Sheikh boys (Mujib's Chalara) carrying guns at the university, and
> now Africa's Mugabe a former freedom fighter, Idi Amin, another
> freedom fighter turning into a Fascist, it is unthinkable. Unlike
> them, after the 7th March Speech, Bangabandu actually collaborated
> with the Pak Army send Rao Farman Ali to Islamabad to save
Pakistan
> and later was fooled and surrendered and stayed the entire period
in
> Pakistan. He never talked about why did he surrender.  If
> Bangabandu's AL didn't have the theoritical backing/blessings from
> our intellectual West Bengali and the Delhi based Dadas that AL is
> a "progressive force", civil  society, fighting against Nizami,
and
> that Bangabandu the father etc, etc.propaganda  via the pro-Indian
> Bangladeshi powerful medias as Daily Star and Prothom Alo etc,
> he would be officially discredited as
> > one of the fighters for democracy who betrayed the nation
to turn
> himself into a dictator and was killed similarly as Mousolini. In
> Europe the above type of people are classified as the Fascist
> leaders. They are discredited in the textbook for committing
> excesses.
> >  
> > It is true, mentioned in the Abul Mansur Ahamed's Amer Dhaka
> Rajnitir Ponchas Botscher and in Azizul Karim's work "From Awami
> League to BAKSAL" that Bangaban du "did not have a clear idea
about
> the difference between party and the state. This became clear even
in
> 1956-57 when he deferred with the then Chief Minister Mr. Ataur
> Rahman Khan. Mr. Khan wanted to keep the administration totally
> neutral. He knew that if the administration were brought under the
> party control then it would be difficult to run the administration
> efficiently. But Sheikh Mujib refuted his contention and said, "The
> administration has to accept party domination. Not only that
> administration will just help and assist the party to execute its
> policies, but the administration will also be helping in increasing
> its influence among the people". Mr. Ataur Rahman Khan had to
> surrender to Sheikh Mujib as he was then considered very powerful
in
> the party. Thus during this time Sheikh Mujibur
> > Rahman as the Minister of Commerce and Industries indulged in
> rampant corruption, nepotism and misuse of power. He used his power
> in giving out permits, licenses, bank loans, and sanction to
> establish industries to people who were loyal to him and his
> cronies."(2) These were the early signs of the then Mujib's Fascist
> tendencies.
> >
> > For the sake of knowledge, Social Scientists have to identify
this
> trend and locate the father of this trend in Bangladesh. It was
this
> type of extremism in Italy that led to Mousalini's death, and the
end
> of Francisco. Like Musolini, to unite people in the independent
> Bangladesh Bangaband u also used extreme nationalism causing the
> alienation of the tribals.
> >  
> > Hasina carries the legacy of Bangabandu. Hasina's AL with its
> Shaschasevok bahini and its alliance of parties (which is
> practically the BAKSAL) continues the trend of anarchy.
> >  
> > Like Bangabandu, Hasina also gives more importance to the party
> interest to gain power than give importance to national
> interest. Hasina' s year round hartal to tire the nation, caused
the
> cancellation of 1996 election that led to the first coming of the
> care-taker government and again in 2007 the chaos led to 1/11  and
> the army backed caretaker government and the uncertainity in the
> nation's life.
> >  
> > (1) Please check the following videos to see that until this
trend
> is not discredited, Bangladesh will have no future!
> >  It is infactious, nowadays everybody is doing it.
> >  
> > (2) I want the readers to please check the historic similarities
> between Bangabandu Mujib and Mosoluni.  We live in an independent
> country, the Fascist chaos of madness against order must be
stopped.
> Bangabandu should be given credit for what he deserve but his
fascist
> tendency should be identified and discouraged as being regressive
to
> Bangladesh's future development. 
> >  
> > Videos on party initiated violence in Bangladesh:
> >  
> >
>
>
>
> Recent Activity
>
>
>  5
> New MembersVisit Your Group
>
>
> Give Back
> Yahoo! for Good
> Get inspired
> by a good cause.
>
> Y! Toolbar
> Get it Free!
> easy 1-click access
> to your groups.
>
> Yahoo! Groups
> Start a group
> in 3 easy steps.
> Connect with others.
> .
>

------------------------------------

[Disclaimer: ALOCHONA Management is not liable for information contained in this message. The author takes full responsibility.]
To unsubscribe/subscribe, send request to alochona-owner@egroups.comYahoo! Groups Links

<*> To visit your group on the web, go to:
http://groups.yahoo.com/group/alochona/

<*> Your email settings:
Individual Email | Traditional

<*> To change settings online go to:
http://groups.yahoo.com/group/alochona/join
(Yahoo! ID required)

<*> To change settings via email:
mailto:alochona-digest@yahoogroups.com
mailto:alochona-fullfeatured@yahoogroups.com

<*> To unsubscribe from this group, send an email to:
alochona-unsubscribe@yahoogroups.com

<*> Your use of Yahoo! Groups is subject to:
http://docs.yahoo.com/info/terms/