Banner Advertiser

Thursday, April 16, 2009

[ALOCHONA] THE MYSTERY VISIT



THE MYSTERY VISIT : Why couldn't Menon wait for nextDelhi govt.?


M I Ali

Last week Shiv Shankar Menon, the Indian Foreign Secretary, came on an unannounced and unscheduled visit to Bangladesh. This is the first of its kind and supposed to be indicative of the close relationship that the Awami League government enjoys with its super power wannabe neighbour India.
   This relationship is now so close that the Indian Foreign Secretary did not feel the need to go through the formality of making formal announcements. It must be noted here that such unannounced visits to 'friendly' countries is not a new phenomenon; US and NATO officials regularly visit Iraq and Afghanistan unscheduled and unannounced.
   It seems that there must have been an urgent need for a high Indian official to visit Bangladesh, a visit that could not have been put off for a later date. The parliamentary elections have just started in India and will go on for over a month ending in mid May. So what could the urgency be? Definitely not to invite a delegation from Bangladesh to inspect the Tepaimukh project in North Eastern India which will deny water to the central and north eastern part of this country, or to exchange pleasantries with political leaders.
   The incumbent Indian government is on its way out and a new government will take over in the next couple of months, the Indian Foreign Secretary therefore could not have been on a routine visit during this period of transition in that country.
   The Director General of BDR has returned from India after meeting his counterpart in the BSF to discuss cooperation between them. Routine visits would have to wait for the outcome of the Indian parliamentary elections which will install a new government in order to be qualified as routine. Some emergency situation must have presented itself to warrant the urgent unannounced visit of the Foreign Secretary and in the absence of any credible explanations from either India or Bangladesh, one is left to speculate the possible reasons for the visit.
   
   Excusive meeting
   First is the nearly one hour exclusive meeting between the Indian Foreign Secretary and the Prime Minister of Bangladesh. It is indeed highly unusual for a Foreign Secretary of another country to have an exclusive meeting with our Prime Minister. Such an official's exclusive meeting should have been the preserve of the Foreign Secretary of our country. Even a one-to-one meeting with the Foreign Minister would have raised some eyebrows; but such a meeting with the Prime Minister has definitely caused a stir among the people.
   The Indian Foreign Secretary then had a similar meeting with the Chief of Army Staff of Bangladesh Army. This is indeed highly unusual. This leads one to wonder what could not wait until the new Indian government to take office, speculators would point their fingers to one direction only.
   The reports of the BDR investigation committees are due to come out before the new Indian government takes office. There are two reports on the BDR that are due to be released. One is the much delayed report of the Committee set up by the government, the submission of whose report has been twice delayed for reasons known only to the Government and the other is the one conducted by the Bangladesh Army. The later report is unlikely to be made public but an official report will be there nonetheless, for the posterity. Was the Indian Foreign Secretary here on a cover-up mission? The nation would definitely want to know the truth.



Menon's Dhaka mission

M. Shahidul Islam

Nothing happens out of the blue, excepting miracles, so believe conscientious humans.
   The sudden visit to Dhaka on April 13-14 of the Indian foreign secretary, Shiv Shankar Menon has given rise to a lot of suspense and wild speculations.
   Suspense in politics, however, often ends up in misery, unless pre-empted in time. The same opinion was rendered by Aristotle who, in his epic composition, Poetics, wrote that suspense would end up either in danger, or in happiness.
   The tragic BDR massacre occurred on the heel of a suspense-ridden environment, following wild fear stirred by some politicians in the parliament and outside about alleged torture in the DGFI custody of some politicians during emergency rule.
   Accompanied by the composition on January 18�of a special committee to render opinion in the validity of the immediate past CG - and the submission of a draft version of the committee report on February 16 - the dreadful suspense entered a phase of climax. Then, barely a week passed by, when an unprecedented rebellion in the BDR managed to kill nearly 60 skilled military officers, ranging from the rank of Captain to Major General.
   
   Forewarning ignored
   With the grace of reflections we can confidently say now that, such a tragic thing could only occur in Bangladesh. As a nation, we not only suffer from forgetfulness, we're also myopic.
   Had that not been the case, how the BDR rebellion could have occurred despite our clearest hints only 5 days ago, in the February 20 issue of Weekly Holiday (Civil-military relations enter murky patch).
   The broader strategy involving the fate of Bangladesh is being implemented by phases. Now that the spotlight is being carefully shifted from the BDR tragedy to the removal of Khaleda Zia from her legitimately owned house, and to the bogey of Islamic militancy, we once again are scared to the hilt by the ongoing deflections and deceptions.
   What really prompted India's external affairs secretary to land in Dhaka on surprise whirlwind tour on April 12? Not only the visit took place amidst Delhi's mammoth preoccupation with the preparation for a general election, sources say there was no mention of such a visit in the official schedule of the Bangladesh PM whom the Indian foreign secretary hurriedly met first, breaching diplomatic protocol, upon arrival in Dhaka.
   "It is really unusual. I have never come across such a surprise visit. Visit by India's external affairs secretary, of course, warrants some preparations," said Shamsher Mubin Chowdhury, a former foreign secretary and an Ambassador. "Only the government can say better why it was kept secret," he added.
   Chowdhury also expressed surprise about Menon's planned meeting with the army chief and the breaching of protocol nuances in the context of a democratic dispensation that Bangladesh claims to have.
   Besides, the arrival of the Indian foreign secretary was kept in such a seamless wrap that, "not only the media, officials in the Prime Minister's Office (PMO) and the foreign ministry were unaware of Menon's possible visit," reported a daily newspaper.
   It was also learnt that Menon's meeting with the PM that began at 7.30 PM on April 13 at her official residence, Jamuna, was hurriedly included in the PM's schedule at the last moment.
   A foreign ministry official said he came to know about the visit "after Menon's arrival to Dhaka" while the First Secretary (Information) of the Indian High Commission, Dipak Mittal, told UNB that it was part of regular consultations with government of a neighbouring and friendly country, nothing beyond that."
   Finally, in a desperate bid to stop speculative headlines to turn things worse, Menon tried to dispel the unease by saying, "We meet regularly. We don't have a set schedule. We meet whenever we feel like. It is part of the ongoing dialogue on various issues between the two countries."


http://www.weeklyholiday.net/front.html#02




__._,_.___


[Disclaimer: ALOCHONA Management is not liable for information contained in this message. The author takes full responsibility.]
To unsubscribe/subscribe, send request to alochona-owner@egroups.com




Your email settings: Individual Email|Traditional
Change settings via the Web (Yahoo! ID required)
Change settings via email: Switch delivery to Daily Digest | Switch to Fully Featured
Visit Your Group | Yahoo! Groups Terms of Use | Unsubscribe

__,_._,___