Banner Advertiser

Tuesday, July 21, 2009

[ALOCHONA] Indian envoy’s arrogant assertions and govt’s undignified silence



Indian envoy's arrogant assertions and govt's undignified silence
 

THE Indian high commissioner, Pinak Ranjan Chakravarty, seems to have embarked on a mission to vitiate further the already-strained relations between Bangladesh and India, making, at regular intervals, statements that are highly objectionable and seek to undermine the dignity and patriotic sentiments of the people in this country. In the past few weeks, he has tried to belittle water experts and environmentalists, and politicians for their opposition to the controversial Indian plan to construct a dam and a barrage on the upstream of the trans-boundary river Barak. Now, it seems, he has chosen the people of Bangladesh in general as the target of his diatribes.


   According to media reports, Chakravarty alleged at a conference on 'Bangladesh-India Economic Relations' in the capital Dhaka on Monday that 80 per cent of the Bangladeshis seeking Indian visa 'are touts and brokers.' Such a remark tends to betray his inherent disdain and disregard for the dignity of the people in Bangladesh on the one hand and his estrangement from the ground reality on the other. The people in Bangladesh and India, especially West Bengal, share a long history that spans not just years but centuries.

 

Many Bangladeshis have relatives in India and vice versa. A significant section of the Indian visa seekers are Bangladeshis planning to visit their relatives on the other side of the border. Yet another sizeable portion of the visa seekers are Bangladeshis who go to India for medical treatment, education and tourism. These people spend millions of dollars in India every year, contributing, in the process, to the growth of the Indian economy. These people mostly make up the long queue in front of the Indian High Commission every day, people whom Chakravarty has so disdainfully branded as 'touts and brokers'.


   Also, according to figures made available by the Federation of Bangladesh Chambers of Commerce and Industry, Bangladesh imported Indian products worth $3.375 billion in the 2007-08 fiscal. If informal trade is taken into account, Bangladesh provides India with a market worth some $5 billion dollars. With New Delhi evidently intent on maintaining the whopping trade imbalance with Dhaka, the least that Bangladesh expects is some sort of recognition, if not expression of gratitude, from India for its contribution to the Indian economy. Instead, as Chakravarty's remark suggests, the Indian high commission in Dhaka seems to be too happy to denigrate Bangladesh and its people every now and then.


   The Indian high commissioner was also quoted as claiming that some 25,000 of the Bangladeshis going to India with legal visas every year do not come back. It may be true that some Bangladeshis stay back in India even after expiry of their visas but it is also true that a good number of Indians reportedly also work in different sectors in Bangladesh, especially in readymade garment and information technology, without valid work permits.

 

In fact, in an era of globalisation, such a phenomenon is almost universal and hardly surprising. What is surprising is that Chakravarty seemingly presumes that India is a lucrative destination for job-seekers, which it hardly is. Indeed, India has registered stupendous economic growth in recent years, at a rate comparable to only China's. However, because of its skewed development model, India's growth has been anything but distributive and has only widened the rich-poor, urban-rural divide. It is a matter of fact that while South Asia is home to half of the world's poor, three-fourths of its poor population lives in India. Also, the Indian society remains incorrigibly segmented along caste and communal lines. Moreover, it is India where hundreds of poor farmers commit suicide every year upon failure to settle their debts with loan sharks and millions of female foetuses have been selectively aborted after pre-natal sex determination to avoid birth of girls since the 1970s. Indeed, the Bangladeshi society has its own share of misery which it has been trying overcome; still, we live in a far better social, economic, political and cultural milieu than our Indian counterparts.


   However, while Chakravarty's words and deeds defy diplomatic norms and minimum human decency, the Awami League-led government's passive response to his obnoxious antics is equally, if not more, deplorable. Not only the government has been ignoring repeated demands of different sections of our society to ask the Indian government to recall Chakravarty, some ministers were found defending the errant diplomat for his offensive remarks only the other day. It is time that government realised that people voted it to power not to take affronts to the dignity of the country from foreign diplomats – Indian or else. The government should also realise that a diplomat like Chakravarty needs to be taken care of for the sake of improving the relationship between the two neighbouring peoples.

 

http://www.newagebd.com/2009/jul/22/edit.html




__._,_.___


[Disclaimer: ALOCHONA Management is not liable for information contained in this message. The author takes full responsibility.]
To unsubscribe/subscribe, send request to alochona-owner@egroups.com




Your email settings: Individual Email|Traditional
Change settings via the Web (Yahoo! ID required)
Change settings via email: Switch delivery to Daily Digest | Switch to Fully Featured
Visit Your Group | Yahoo! Groups Terms of Use | Unsubscribe

__,_._,___