Dear Abid>
Are you a paid attack dog for Munshi? From where you got the idea, that he is an outstanding intellectual of our time? Can you send me a single publication from Munshi in any prestigious journal in America or Europe? There is another worshipper like you, who edited Munshi's India Doctrine. His qualifications to write a book review? He has a master's degree in sociology from Bangladesh! Lord have mercy—this satisfies your criteria for intellectualism? Here is a challenge for you and MBI Munshi. Submit India Doctrine to New York Times book Review editor for an intellectual analysis. If NY Time verifies that Mr.Munshi's assertions, innuendos, accusations and speculative statements have basis in fact---I will give Mr.Munshi—the Key to my house in Washington D.C. However, if the NY Times say, it is wildly speculative book with lots of personal opinion, unfounded fear, and uncorroborated statements---then Mr.Abid, what is my recompense? Nobody is talking about unconditional surrender of one's sovereignty. We are talking about common sense. If you read the Muslim History for the last 300 years, you will notice, how foolishly the Muslims have acted to their great detriment. I stand by my argument against Imam Hussein's foolishness. Why the Imam with 72 men , women, and children decided to fight an organized army of 10,000? If martyrdom was the object---why he took the children along? Why he did not chose to die like Jesus of Nazareth on the cross by himself and make his point for the mankind? Use your God given common sense and you will never call him a Shaheed. All along, the writing was on the wall---but the Munshis of this world---always defeated the voices of Reason. Every single Muslim country is taking dictation from the White Masters of today. Every Single Muslim Country is on the way to become a 'failed state' ---with the Americans and the Europeans are getting ready to deal with the Army led governments. I know, you will point to Iran as a good example of a sovereign state. Not really---they are totally banking on Russia to save them from the Americans. They are bribing the Russian officials and giving no bid contracts to government approved contractors. In case you have forgotten—Saddam also bribed the Russians to the tune of Billions. How long you will keep your head in the sand like an ostrich and pretend that you and people of your ilk are sovereign and you don't take no-shit from nobody? If you use your head, you will observe---the Muslim world is engulfed in Militancy movements. Don't you see why that's the case? Let me help you understand. You and Munshi are the type I am talking about. Both of you are the symbol of militant Islam---bold, reckless, sense-less, suicidal, materialistic, sparing nothing, fearing nothing, and contemptuous of the infidel powers. This militancy---which is fueling radicalism in the Muslim world---I am afraid-- may culminate in the 3rd world war. And that's exactly what you, Munshi, and the greatest Intellectual of Islam Allama Iqbal want. Says he---"You (Allah) have made them, (The Muslims) indifferent to the riches of the world, by instilling your love divine into their hearts. Except for the love of Jehad and the joy of martyrdom, the kingdom of the earth holds no attraction for them. This is the magic of Your Love Divine. It is the last wish and the greatest desire of a true Muslim". Says it all Abid, doesn't it?
SaifDevdas
islam1234@msn.com
From: SAIF Davdas <islam1234@msn.com>
To: 6064@yahoogroups.com; abdul_momen@hotmail.com; abidbahar@yahoo.com; abutaher@gmail.com; Afroj Jahan <shurovies.coll@gmail.com>; "afsaruddin2000@yahoo.com" <afsaruddin2000@yahoo.com>; Aftab Kazmi <aftab_kazmi@hotmail.com>; Ajmol ali <ajmol.ali@treas.state.nj.us>; "akhter@erols.com" <akhter@erols.com>; aknahkhan@yahoo.com; Alamgir <malamgir1@aol.com>; albarakat@intermaxinc.com; ali_a_chowdhury@hotmail.com; Alochana <alochona@yahoogroups.com>; anisahmed63@yahoo.com; Asif <manonbike2@yahoo.com>; ask@citechco.net; Atiq <atq111@yahoo.com>; awahed@hotmail.com; ayesha_rahman21@hotmail.com; ayeshakabir@yahoo.com; azmalhaidar@yahoo.com; "baainews@yahoo.com" <baainews@yahoo.com>; banglanari <banglarnari@yahoogroups.com>; beautyanwar@hotmail.com; ben <ben_inda@yahoo.com>; bidrohee@yahoo.com; bushra <bushrakhan24@gmail.com>; caphurdi@dhaka.net; "celeti@aol.com" <celeti@aol.com>; chabinazrul@yahoo.com; charbak_bd@yahoo.com; chowdhuryhkhan@yahoo.com; dhuq@msn.com; dick_timm@yahoo.com; dip1971@hotmail.com; faisal.quader@gxs.com; Fareez Ahmed <fareez.ahmed@gmail.com>; farhadmazhar@hotmail.com; faria_shukhee@hotmail.com; farida_majid@hotmail.com; faruk ahmed <farukahmed_bd@yahoo.com>; frahman@telesat.com; fsobhan@hotmail.com; g_faroo1@hotmail.com; gmehraj@aol.com
Sent: Wednesday, March 4, 2009 9:54:35 PM
Subject: MILITANCY-MBI MUNSHI
Dear Friends>
MBI Munshi, you write---"Creation of a regional task force with tactical operations capabilities and extra-territorial functions could threaten the internal stability of the country and make it a target for insurgents and terrorists who had until now posed no threat to Bangladesh's interests". Very interesting indeed!
I would argue, my dear Munshi, more than our national security or dignity---common sense dictates---unprecedented international cooperation. We must cooperate with the CIA, the FBI, the Raw, the ISI, and the British MI and prevent terrorists from taking advantage of national and international borders.
You write, "For India to secure its political and military supremacy and control over the South Asian region it has become necessary for it to continuously maintain and protect her lead over other economies even by unfair means such as sabotage, fomenting and encouraging political instability in neighboring countries". My question to You Mr.Munshi---What the Bangladesh should do against Indian hegemony? Are you asking your followers to follow the great Imam Hussein and commit suicide? Imam Hussein, with 72 men, women and children—as young as one month old-- decided to fight 10,000 strong cavalry of Yazid in Kerbala. Instead of seeing how foolish the Imam was---Muslims see him as a great leader! If Nuclear powered Pakistan cannot shoot down even one of our 'Pilotless Drone' over Islamabad---where is the wisdom in your militant stance against India? Are you relying on Flocks of Birds from Allah for protection as Allah protected Kaabaa in 570 AD?
Intellectual and moral Bankruptcy of your anti-India posture is truly sickening. Your venomous attack on India surpasses the foolishness of Hamas and Hezbollah's militant anti-Israel stance. The US, the Russians, and the EU have already declared---the next century will be an Indian and Chinese century. Only the militant Pakis and you think otherwise on this very vital issue. The Indians, armed with the largest Scientist force in the world, are beating the hell out of the Americans in every field. In last five years, more than Three Million Indians left USA for lucrative jobs in India. Doesn't common sense dictate that we the Bangladeshis also recognize this reality and act accordingly? After Mangle Pandey's revolution against the British in 1857---the wise Hindus, decided to beat the Brits by obeying them and learn from them. As a result, the British built the finest engineering schools in India---owing to that, India landed on Moon in 2008! Back then, the Muslims listened to scholars like you---not that Kafir Sir Syed Ahmed Khan---with devastating and disastrous far reaching consequences for the Muslims of the world! Islamic history of last 1000 years is replete with these militant voices. How very sad and unfortunate indeed. Will we Muslims ever learn?
SaifDevdas
islam1234@msn.com
_t.
Windows Live™: Life without walls. Check it out.
Windows Live™ Contacts: Organize your contact list. Check it out.
Express your personality in color! Preview and select themes for Hotmail®. See how.
__._,_.___